Maybelline : define a line eyeliner review

The Maybelline : define a line eyeliner sucks, the worst eyeliner I have ever bought. I bought the slate gray one, it was already dully sharpen. It was too creamy. It gave my a bold line. It also smudge all over my lower lid, while I kept blinking. And I have no idea where the built-in sharpener is and how to sharpen it too, the tip has became a flat surface already. I also can't find a how to video or instructions online. Maybe it just doesn't work on my asian eyes, whatever, it was a waste of my $4 and something and wasn't a look I was thinking of. Maybe I should buy a waterproof one next time or start using liquid eyeliner.